What Is Better For Home - A Projector Or A TV? Which One To Choose - A Large TV Or A Projector? Can A Projector Replace A TV?

2024 Author: Beatrice Philips | [email protected]. Last modified: 2023-12-16 05:33

For viewing movies, modern technologies offer two options for devices: projectors and televisions. The variety of technical and operational parameters makes the choice between them very difficult, since each of these devices has its own advantages and disadvantages. When buying, you should take into account a huge number of various factors, from the content being broadcast to the shade of the walls in the hall.

Features of the projector

A projector in homes has been used not so long ago, despite the fact that a similar option for viewing video recordings itself arose in the middle of the last century. Since that moment, the device has gone through a rather impressive evolutionary path, and today moviegoers increasingly prefer this particular setting instead of a standard TV. This choice is explained by the large number of advantages of this system:

• large screen;
• slight load on vision;
• laconic design;
• compact size;
• clarity and naturalness of shades;
• the ability to view 3D.

To display the image in the projectors, light rays reflected from small mirrors are used, thanks to which the eyes almost do not experience fatigue while watching movies, which in general makes the picture realistic and largely reduces the visual load.

When it comes to design, the choice between a projector and a regular TV is obvious . Despite all the efforts of the companies producing television equipment, the projector looks much more harmonious in the context of any interior. The working device creates a warm atmosphere of a home theater, brings comfort and peace to it.

Home projectors are lightweight and small in size, a factor that is important when moving. In addition, such equipment can always be taken with you to a country house or dacha.

Nevertheless, the device also has a number of significant disadvantages. These include:

• increased level of noise production;
• the need for frequent cleaning from dust;
• rainbow effect;
• short lamp life in combination with the high cost of replacing it;
• the presence of a reflective screen;
• the need for thorough darkening of the room;
• the requirement for finishing the premises in dark colors.

The projectors hum and collect dust particles. Even if the manufacturer assures that the device is absolutely dustproof, nevertheless it still has to be cleaned regularly . Watching films is best done at night. If you plan to sit near the screen during the day, you will have to darken the windows and carefully prepare the room. So that the luminous flux coming from the device does not scatter, and the picture turns out to be clear and saturated, it is best to install the projector in a living room, the walls of which are painted in a dark gray, blue or black shade.

Lamps in projectors have a rather limited lifespan - as a rule, it is 2 thousand hours, and to replace this element, you will have to pay up to 40-50% of the cost of the projector itself. It is this drawback that many users consider the main one, refusing to buy such a device in favor of a traditional TV.

A necessary attribute for the use of projectors is a reflective screen; its arrangement also requires material costs. Usually it is made of PVC material, lavsan or raincoat fabric.

TV specifications

Along with fans of cinematic art, as well as professionals who give an absolute preference to cinema projectors, there is a large group of lovers of traditional TV equipment.

The television technology, familiar to everyone, is undoubtedly convenient . But, like projectors, it has not only its advantages, but also disadvantages.

Modern TVs have one significant advantage - high picture quality. The equipment produced in recent years provides natural color reproduction and exceptional contrast, making watching films, programs and TV shows as comfortable as possible.

It is noteworthy that the lighting does not affect the convenience of viewing in any way: neither bright sunlight nor an artificial lamp can lead to a loss in the quality of the transmitted image.

The breadth of the assortment presented in the stores also speaks in favor of television technology. Today the market offers a huge selection of various models, so each user can always choose the best option for himself, depending on personal preferences and financial capabilities. While the choice of projectors is extremely scarce, and some price categories are even represented by a couple of models.

TVs are easy to use, usually users do not have any difficulties with connecting and setting up equipment

You can turn the TV on and off at any time, no preliminary preparation of the room is required. According to this parameter, the device is much more practical and functional than projectors - you just need to press the power button, and after a couple of seconds the screen will light up.

For comparison, to turn on the projector, you need to do a lot of additional actions: draw the curtains, open the screen, and then wait a few more minutes until the equipment lamp warms up to the desired state.

However, in order for the picture to be as true and correct as possible, it is worth dwelling on the disadvantages of televisions.

The diagonal size of the TV is most directly reflected in its cost: the larger the screen, the higher the price. In order to install a cinema at home, you will need equipment with a diagonal of about 2 meters, and this will be very expensive. If you buy a small TV, you are unlikely to get much pleasure from watching widescreen films.

Prolonged TV viewing has the most adverse effect on the organs of vision, since the eyes at this moment are always directed to the light source, and not its reflection, as is the case in cinemas.

The working matrix of all modern liquid crystal and plasma screens is very vulnerable to any mechanical stress . Even a slight impact can damage and destroy the screen.

What's better?

Remembering all the advantages and disadvantages of projectors and TVs, you can draw some conclusions and establish which decision will be correct.

If we mention the size, then in the past, television equipment did not match the capabilities of a projector in terms of screen size … Nowadays, it is already quite possible to buy an 85-inch TV that costs 3-4 thousand dollars. At the same time, a 120-inch projection screen will cost much less, while the projector itself will cost about 1.5 thousand dollars. If you plan to organize a real large home theater in your living room, then it is best to use a projector with a screen - such a solution will not come out so expensive.

Brightness - this parameter is especially relevant, since it affects the quality of the picture, which can vary depending on the characteristics of the lighting in the house . The brighter the living room, the brighter the video source should be - this is the only way to get a rich image.

A high-brightness projector costs a lot more than a TV. So, the overwhelming majority of models in the price segment of the order of 2 thousand dollars give a brightness flux with a parameter from 1, 5 to 3 thousand lumens. If we talk about television equipment, then the majority of modern devices achieve much more successful indicators.

At the same time, if you install the projector in a dark room, then even the weakest stream will provide a high quality image, while the eyes will get tired from the projection screen much less than from the TV.

Summarizing all of the above, you can make simple recommendations

• If you prefer HD movies and appreciate cinematic special effects, which can only be fully appreciated in a cinema on a large surround screen, then, without a doubt, you are better off choosing a projector.
• If you are a fan of watching films and analogue broadcasts, from time to time you turn on the broadcasts of sports and news releases, then your needs will be more than adequately satisfied by a plasma panel or LCD TV.
• However, both of these devices are aimed at solving a specifically outlined range of tasks. If the budget allows, then it is better to buy both a TV and a projector.