Oak And Beech: Which Is Better And Stronger? Comparison Of Dry Boards And Other Sawn Timber. What Is Stronger, Harder And More Expensive? How To Distinguish Oak From Beech?

2024 Author: Beatrice Philips | [email protected]. Last modified: 2023-12-16 05:33

Which is better: oak or beech is an incorrect question, although beech is always ranked second in the ratings of high-quality wood because of its density, which is noticeably inferior to that of the leader. However, ash, which is practically not inferior to oak in strength and hardness, in terms of the richness of the structure of lumber, is more common in temperate climates, is inferior to beech in demand, although it is ideal for some needs. A definite and motivated answer in determining the advantages of wood depends on the purpose of use and the need for the type of processing. We will consider all this in the article.

What is stronger?

Strength and density are important criteria in assessing the quality of lumber, but all comparisons are made in terms of strictly defined needs - for example, what is better to take for the manufacture of furniture or a wooden staircase, in the construction of a facade or for interior decoration. The oak has a density of 720 cubic meters. m, but behind him in the top three in demand is not ash, with an excellent indicator of 690 kg per cubic meter. m, and beech, which has a lower density - 660 kg per cubic meter. m.

Trees belong to class B - solid wood, but this category also includes common birch, elm, sycamore, walnut, maple and apple trees, which are less demanded by builders. There is also category B - with very hard wood - iron birch, acacia, hornbeam and pistachio wood, used only in some cases for the manufacture of furniture or building decoration. It can be assumed that, in addition to the strength indicator, there are other selection criteria:

• ease of processing, rich texture;
• resistance to pests and moisture;
• the need for processing to give individual properties;
• growth features - resin, twigs and branches, the formation of knots in the texture;
• duration of operation, possible without additional processing measures;
• ease of bringing lumber in line with existing needs;
• prevalence on sale or rare;
• price category (not everyone can afford luxury furniture or the highest quality wood).

Furniture manufacturers recognize beech as a relatively cheap version of oak. It is difficult for amateurs to distinguish beech furniture from oak furniture. However, in the choice of priorities, the cornerstone is not the indicator, which is stronger, but a balanced analysis of the advantages and disadvantages - oak furniture is very expensive (the lion's share of the budget is the cost of wood). But it is heavy and can crack, and the cheaper one is often a fake. Beech is difficult to repair, cracks and does not tolerate moisture well (hygroscopic), and requires specific care.

Therefore, you can often find recommendations to select wood not by density or hardness, but by a number of evaluation criteria . One of the most important factors for furniture is the ease of processing, the purpose of the furniture and the peculiarities of the interior situation in the living room. In construction, the bearing capacity of the foundation is taken into account - lumber is heavy and can deform, give a load for which the foundation is not designed.

But if we evaluate strength from the point of view of density, then oak takes the first place in the top three, and beech - only the third, yielding to ash. Although both types of wood without a stretch fall into the small category of solid.

Comparison of other characteristics

The highest quality wood is considered to be old oak, which in natural conditions can live for a thousand years. The longer a tree grows, which can reach a girth of two meters, the harder and more beautiful it is in texture, especially when cut radially. In carpentry, oak wood is in demand with an age from 150 years to a 2-century period. Further, the hardness increases, and with it the complexity of processing. If you need a well frame, a barrel, river piles or interior decoration of the premises, lumber will not meet worthy competition.

Furniture is in demand due to the ability to quickly bleach, give any shades, resist fungus and mold due to the presence of natural antiseptics. It is always more expensive, but there are considerations of designers who are sure that an oak set is inappropriate in a small room or a small apartment, although the manufacturers claim that oak furniture can decorate almost any room.

Beech has its advantages:

• at first glance, and even without professional knowledge, it is impossible to distinguish between beech and oak furniture;
• it is often more beautiful due to its ability to be easier to process, maintain the desired shade even after applying several layers of varnish, undergo a drying process and not crack;
• if we compare the appearance and cost, then the difference (and significant) often motivates in favor of beech on two indicators;
• not understanding the peculiarities of wood, you can easily come across a fake from an unscrupulous manufacturer and buy beech furniture instead of oak;
• in turn, beech products are not often counterfeited and the source used is honestly positioned, so you will not have to overpay.

If we are not talking about furniture, but about finishing or building stairs in the house, it is always taken into account that oak is denser, lasts longer and withstands mechanical stress. In addition, it is the undisputed leader in moisture resistance, therefore it is appropriate in a bathhouse and on the street.

If dry boards were used during construction, the service life of the finish or staircase is practically unlimited. There is an opinion that oak, even if it is an edged board, has a special positive energy.

What is the best choice?

In response to this question, it is customary to appeal to taking into account the needs and financial capabilities of a particular consumer, place of application, decorative properties. For people with unlimited opportunities to invest in the construction of a private house or a country mansion, a bathhouse for their own needs or for commercial profit, oak wood is preferable. It is denser and stronger, it serves for a long time, it is considered a sign of respectability and prosperity of the owners, it is resistant to moisture, fungi and mold . Oak is also favored by its decorative effect and effective texture. There is a special charm in the ability of the tree to darken over time, acquiring a noble shade, in its unique scent, vaguely reminiscent of vanilla.

Beech has its own, special advantages - low (in comparison with oak) cost, the ability to acquire beautiful shapes and unusual configurations under the action of mechanical processing. As with oak, its striking texture, density and strength are valued. When making a choice in favor of a gold or silver medalist, you should not focus only on cost, persistent advertising slogans or the opinion of others . You need to take into account the scope, your needs and capabilities.

Both oak and beech belong to the category of solid, sought-after, durable trees with excellent characteristics. Therefore, the consumer has the right to weigh all the arguments for and against and make his own, balanced choice.